Venue: Committee Room 3 - Civic Suite. View directions
Contact: Troy Robinson 0208 3149365
None were declared.
RESOLVED that the minutes of the Committee meetings held on the 11
December 2014 and 26 March 2015 be approved as a correct record and
signed by the Chair.
Paul Aladenika, Principal Policy Officer, introduced the report and explained
that this is a standard report presented to the Committee annually.
A brief discussion followed and it was commented that the implementation of
Modern.Gov was a good idea. It was further commented that the use of actual
examples throughout the review was to be commended.
An enquiry was raised as to whether any information on the Lewisham
Congress which met in October 2014 had been published. Paul Aladenika
agreed to make such information available to members of the Committee.
It was also clarified that the outcomes of the Peer Review were reported to
Business Panel and Overview & Scrutiny Committees as well as to the Mayor
RESOLVED that the outcomes of the review be endorsed.
Helen Glass, Deputy Monitoring Officer, introduced the report and explained
there had been two referrals since the last report considered by the Standards
In relation to Case A, the Monitoring Officer had referred the matter to the
Executive Director Children and Young People Directorate (CYP) for the
matter to be dealt with in accordance with the Directorate’s procedures.
Alan Docksey, Head of Resources, CYP, explained to the Committee that on
receipt of the complaint, which related to staffing and management issues at a
school, it was felt appropriate for the issues to be investigated and responded
to by the school and consequently the matter was passed to the Chair of
It was further explained that there had recently been a significant amount of
change at the school. The Governing Body had been dissolved and replaced
with an Interim Executive Board (IEB). This matter was being progressed by
the IEB although there was an acknowledgement due to the passage of time
and staff changes that matters may be more challenging to deal with at this
stage. Schools Human Resources Team would assist and offer a view as they
are contracted to provide human resources advice to the school and would
have knowledge of some of the issues raised.
It was commented that it was for the Council in dealing with complaints
brought under the whistleblowing policy to demonstrate independence and
that it would be appropriate to seek to obtain some corroboration of the
matters complained about before forwarding the matter to the school .
It was suggested that the better course of action would have been for the
matter to be investigated by the Council and not simply referred to the school.
An effective whistleblowing policy must instil confidence that people can raise
issues and that those issues will be properly investigated.
There were some comparable comments in relation to Case B. It was also
asked that as that complaint related to safeguarding was there not a different
procedure to be adopted. Officers explained that where complaints are made
about safeguarding these are always matters of serious concern and CYP
Directorate will always look for corroboration. However where the complainant
is anonymous and no school identified, in the absence of any further
information, it is very difficult to know how to progress.
It was noted that it seemed to be a generic response that enquiries about
schools are referred to the school/governing body. A request was made for
the Children & Young Person’s Directorate procedures to be submitted to the
In response to an enquiry about timescales in relation to Case A it was
confirmed that this had not been agreed with the IEB. It was agreed that
information in relation to timescales will be referred back to the Committee.
In relation to Case B members enquired whether the response from the
Monitoring Officer had been sufficiently proactive. The Deputy Monitoring
Officer informed the Committee that she did not have knowledge of the actual
complaint but explained that ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Appointments to Sub-Committees
RESOLVED that Councillors Dacres, Adefiranye, Bell, Elliott, Mallory, and
Gill Butler and Leslie Thomas be members of Standards Sub Committee A.
Councillors Hooks, Bourne, Hall, Moore, Morrison and Cathy Sullivan and
David Roper-Newman be members of Standards Sub Committee B.
The meeting ended at 7:50pm